The disciplinary process follows a logical lifecycle divided into Incident, Inquiry, and Action. It begins with the Incident phase, where the alleged misconduct is detected, a preliminary investigation establishes a prima facie case, and a formal Charge Sheet is served to the employee. If the charge is denied, the process moves to the Inquiry phase, a quasi-judicial stage where an impartial Inquiry Officer records evidence, allows cross-examination, and ensures the Principles of Natural Justice are followed to determine guilt or innocence. Finally, the Action phase concludes the matter, where the Disciplinary Authority reviews the inquiry findings, provides the employee a copy of the report, and issues a final speaking order imposing a penalty or exonerating the employee based on the proven facts.Phase 1: The Pre-Inquiry Stage
1. Preliminary Investigation (Fact-Finding)
Purpose: To determine if there is a prima facie case (sufficient initial evidence) against the employee.
Action: Management collects complaints, witness statements and documentary proof.
Result: If the misconduct appears genuine, proceed to the charge sheet.
2. Drafting and Issuing the Charge Sheet
Requirement: The charge sheet must be precise and unambiguous.
Details to Include:
Date, time, and location of the incident.
Specific clause/number of the Standing Orders or Service Rules that was violated.
A list of witnesses and documents (evidence) management intends to rely on.
Service: Must be served via Hand Delivery (with signature) or Registered Post/Speed Post.
3. Consideration of Explanation
The employee is given a specific timeframe (e.g., 48, 72, or 96 hours) to submit a written explanation.
If Satisfactory: The case is dropped or a simple warning is issued.
If Unsatisfactory (or no reply received): Management decides to hold a domestic inquiry.
4. Appointment of Officials
Management issues a formal order appointing:
Inquiry Officer (IO): The judge of the proceedings (must be impartial). Click here for Draft Order of Appointment of Inquiry Officer
Presenting Officer (PO): Represents the management/company side.
Phase 2: The Inquiry Proceedings
5. Notice of Inquiry
The Inquiry Officer (IO) issues a notice to the employee (Charge-Sheeted Employee or CSE) stating the Date, Time, and Venue of the first hearing.
Advisable: Provide 7-10 days' notice for the first hearing.
6. First Hearing (Preliminary)
Recording Presence: The IO records the names of everyone present.
Defense Assistance: The IO asks the employee if they need a "Defense Assistant" (co-worker/union rep).
Plea: The IO reads the charges and asks: "Do you admit or deny the charges?"
Admit: Recording of admission and closure of evidence.
Deny: The inquiry proceeds to the evidence stage.
7. Management Evidence (Prosecution)
Examination-in-Chief: The PO questions management witnesses to prove the charges.
Cross-Examination: The employee/Defense Assistant questions management witnesses to test their testimony.
Exhibits: Documents are formally marked (e.g., Ex-M1, Ex-M2) and signed by the IO.
8. Defense Evidence
Examination-in-Chief: The employee questions their own witnesses.
Cross-Examination: The PO questions the defense witnesses.
Statement: The employee may choose to testify themselves.
9. General Examination (Court Questions)
The IO may ask the employee clarifying questions regarding the evidence presented against them to give them a final opportunity to explain.
10. Written Briefs
The IO may request both the PO and the Defense to submit written closing arguments summarizing their respective cases.
Phase 3: The Verdict & Final Order
11. Inquiry Report (Findings)
The IO analyzes the evidence and writes a reasoned report.
Conclusion: The IO states if charges are "Proved," "Partially Proved," or "Not Proved."
Note: The IO does NOT decide the punishment.
12. Supply of Report (Second Show Cause)
The Disciplinary Authority (DA) sends a copy of the Inquiry Report to the employee.
Opportunity: The employee is given time (e.g., 7-15 days) to submit a representation challenging the IO's findings.
13. Final Decision and Penalty Order
The DA reviews the employee's reply.
Order: The DA issues a final "Speaking Order" (order with reasons) imposing a penalty (e.g., Suspension, Demotion, Dismissal) based on the gravity of the misconduct.
Critical HR Checklist
[ ] Daily Order Sheets: Ensure a daily sheet is written and signed by all parties for every hearing date.
[ ] Service Proof: Keep postal receipts and acknowledgments for every notice sent.
[ ] Impartiality: Ensure the Inquiry Officer is not a witness or directly connected to the incident.
[ ] Natural Justice: Ensure the employee was given ample opportunity to cross-examine witnesses.
No comments:
Post a Comment